Living in highrise buildings associated with lower survival rates from cardiac arrests, study finds, recommending more AEDs, better access for first responders
Toronto, January 18, 2016
By Leslie Shepherd
The number of people living in highrise buildings in rising, but along with the convenience and panoramic views of a downtown condo comes a risk: a new study found that survival rates from cardiac arrest decrease the higher up the building a person lives.
“Cardiac arrests that occur in highrise buildings pose unique barriers for 911-initiated first responders,” said Ian Drennan, lead author of the study published today in the Canadian Medical Association Journal.
“Building access issues, elevator delays and extended distance from the emergency vehicle to the patient can all contribute to longer times for 911-initiated first responders to reach the patient and start time-sensitive, potentially life-saving resuscitation,” he said.
Drennan is a paramedic with York Region Paramedic Services and a researcher with Rescu, a group based at St. Michael’s Hospital that studies emergency health care that begins outside of a hospital.
Looking at data from 8,216 adults who suffered an out-of-hospital cardiac arrest treated by 911-initiated first responders in the City of Toronto and nearby Peel Region from January 2007 to December 2012, they found 3.8 per cent survived until they could be discharged from a hospital. Survival was 4.2 per cent for people living below the third floor and 2.6 per cent for people living on or above the third floor.
But Drennan said when they went back and looked at the exact floor the patients lived on, they found decreased survival rates as the floors got higher. Survival above the 16th floor was 0.9 per cent (of 216 cases, only two survived). There were no survivors to hospital discharge of the 30 cardiac arrests above the 25th floor.
“Patients who survived tended to be younger, their cardiac arrest was more often witnessed by bystanders, and bystanders were more likely to perform CPR,” Drennan said, noting the rate of bystander AED use was very low in this study. “They also had shorter times for 911-initiated first responders to get to the scene and to the patient.”
While this study was intended to compare the rate of survival to hospital discharge for cardiac arrests that occur on higher versus lower floors of residential buildings, it also highlighted the fact that response times for 911-initiated first responders are traditionally measured from the time a call is received by the 911 dispatch centre to when the first emergency vehicle arrives on the scene. But Drennan said this measure does not take into account the time required for 911-initiated first responders to reach the patient after they arrive on the scene and can begin resuscitation.
“After collapse from sudden cardiac arrest, early bystander CPR and a shock from a publicly accessible automated external defibrillator can make the difference between life and death,” Drennan said. “Effective CPR performed by a bystander immediately after cardiac arrest can more than double a person’s chance of survival, but only 30 per cent of cardiac arrest victims get CPR from a bystander. With a rapidly deteriorating heart rhythm, in the absence of bystander CPR and defibrillation, cardiac arrests that occurred on higher floors may have a lower probability of survival due to the delay to patient contact by 911-initiated first responders. This early period is essential for bystander interventions by a family member, friend or other willing person to improve survival.”
He said another possible explanation for lower survival at higher floors is that it simply takes longer to get patients out of the building.
The study made several recommendations:
- Improving the accessibility of AEDs by placing them on specific floors, in building lobbies or inside elevators so that they can be easily delivered to the floor of the cardiac arrest, saving precious minutes and ensuring rapid defibrillation.
- Give paramedics a universal elevator key similar to what firefighters have, giving them sole access to elevators without public interference
- Find ways to alert building security to the fact 911-initiated first responders are en route so they can have easy access to the building and elevators waiting on the main floor
Overall, the study said there was a 20 per cent increase in the rate of cardiac arrests suffered in private residences over the years of the study. In roughly the same time, 2006 to 2011, the number of people living in highrise buildings grew by 13 per cent in Toronto. Many of those people are older, with higher rates of serious medical issues and higher risk of cardiac arrest.
This study received funding from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research and the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada.
This paper is an example of how St. Michael's Hospital is making Ontario Healthier, Wealthier, Smarter.
About St. Michael's Hospital
St. Michael’s Hospital provides compassionate care to all who enter its doors. The hospital also provides outstanding medical education to future health care professionals in 27 academic disciplines. Critical care and trauma, heart disease, neurosurgery, diabetes, cancer care, care of the homeless and global health are among the hospital’s recognized areas of expertise. Through the Keenan Research Centre and the Li Ka Shing International Healthcare Education Centre, which make up the Li Ka Shing Knowledge Institute, research and education at St. Michael's Hospital are recognized and make an impact around the world. Founded in 1892, the hospital is fully affiliated with the University of Toronto.
For more information or to arrange an interview with Dr. Khan, please contact:
Manager, Media Strategy, St. Michael's Hospital